Hey guys! Craving some delicious Italian food but don't feel like dining in? No worries! Ithaca, New York, has got you covered with some fantastic Italian carryout options. Let's dive into the best spots where you can grab a taste of Italy to enjoy at home, in the park, or wherever your heart desires. This guide will walk you through the top places, what makes them special, and why you should definitely check them out.

Top Italian Carryout Restaurants in Ithaca

When it comes to Italian carryout in Ithaca, you're in for a treat. Ithaca boasts a vibrant food scene, and its Italian offerings are no exception. From classic pasta dishes to mouth-watering pizzas, there’s something for everyone. Here are some of the top restaurants you should definitely consider:

1. Pasta Plus

Pasta Plus is a local favorite known for its generous portions and authentic flavors. If you're looking for a hearty meal that tastes like it came straight from Nonna's kitchen, this is the place to go. Their menu is packed with classic Italian dishes, and everything is made fresh daily. The aroma alone is enough to make your mouth water! They have been serving the Ithaca community for years, becoming a staple for those craving a comforting and satisfying Italian meal. One of their standout features is the ability to customize your pasta dish. You choose your pasta type, sauce, and add-ins, ensuring you get exactly what you're craving. This level of personalization, combined with their commitment to quality ingredients, sets them apart from other Italian eateries in the area. Whether you are a student looking for a quick and affordable meal or a family wanting a comforting dinner, Pasta Plus offers something for everyone. The friendly staff and efficient service make it a pleasant experience every time, solidifying its reputation as a go-to spot for Italian comfort food in Ithaca.

Their lasagna is a must-try – layers of pasta, rich meat sauce, and creamy cheese, baked to perfection. The spaghetti carbonara is another popular choice, featuring perfectly cooked pasta tossed in a creamy sauce with crispy pancetta and a generous sprinkle of Parmesan cheese. Don't forget to try their garlic knots – they're addictive!

2. Gorgers Subs

While Gorgers Subs might not be exclusively Italian, their Italian sub is legendary. Packed with layers of cured meats, provolone cheese, and a tangy vinaigrette, it’s the perfect quick and satisfying lunch or dinner option. Gorgers Subs has become an Ithaca institution, renowned for its creative and generously filled submarine sandwiches. While their menu spans various flavors and culinary influences, the Italian sub stands out as a consistent crowd-pleaser. The combination of high-quality ingredients and meticulous preparation makes each bite an experience. The bread, sourced locally, provides the perfect chewy yet firm foundation for the layers of thinly sliced cured meats, which include salami, prosciutto, and capicola. These are complemented by sharp provolone cheese, crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and thinly sliced onions, all brought together by a tangy vinaigrette that adds a zing. Each sub is made to order, ensuring freshness and allowing for customization to suit individual preferences. Beyond the quality of the ingredients, it’s the dedication to crafting the perfect balance of flavors and textures that elevates Gorgers Subs' Italian sub above the competition. Whether you are a long-time resident or a visitor exploring Ithaca's culinary scene, stopping by Gorgers Subs for their iconic Italian sub is a must. It’s a true testament to how a simple sandwich can become a beloved local treasure.

3. Franco's Pizzeria

For pizza lovers, Franco's Pizzeria is a must-visit. This family-owned pizzeria uses traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients to create some of the best pies in town. From classic margherita to loaded meat lovers, there’s a pizza for every palate. Franco's Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of the Ithaca community for decades, serving up classic, New York-style pizzas that have won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. This family-owned establishment prides itself on using time-honored recipes and the freshest, highest-quality ingredients to create pizzas that are consistently delicious. The dough, made fresh daily, is hand-tossed and baked to a perfect crisp, providing a sturdy yet airy base for their array of toppings. Their signature sauce, a closely guarded family recipe, adds a tangy and slightly sweet flavor that complements the creamy mozzarella cheese. Whether you are a fan of a simple Margherita with fresh basil or prefer a loaded meat lovers' pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, Franco's offers a pizza for every palate. In addition to their classic pies, they also feature a selection of specialty pizzas, such as the veggie supreme and the white pizza with ricotta and garlic. Beyond the quality of their pizzas, Franco's is known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere. The friendly staff treats every customer like family, creating a sense of community that keeps people coming back. The aroma of baking dough and bubbling cheese fills the air, adding to the overall experience. Franco's Pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a quick slice; it's a place to gather with friends and family, share a meal, and create memories. It’s a true testament to the power of good food and good company.

Their garlic knots are also a big hit, brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese – the perfect appetizer to share (or not!). The staff are super friendly and always ready to help you choose the perfect pizza.

4. Thompson & Bleecker

If you are leaning more towards the upscale end, Thompson & Bleecker offers Italian dishes with a modern twist. They use locally sourced ingredients to create innovative and flavorful dishes that are perfect for a special night in. Thompson & Bleecker brings a sophisticated touch to the Ithaca dining scene, offering Italian-inspired dishes that blend traditional flavors with modern culinary techniques. This restaurant stands out for its commitment to using locally sourced and seasonal ingredients, ensuring that each dish is fresh, flavorful, and reflective of the region's bounty. The menu is thoughtfully curated, featuring a range of appetizers, entrees, and desserts that showcase the chefs' creativity and expertise. Their handmade pasta dishes are a particular highlight, with options like butternut squash ravioli, truffle risotto, and seafood linguine. Each pasta is cooked to perfection and paired with complementary sauces and toppings that elevate the dish to new heights. In addition to their pasta offerings, Thompson & Bleecker also features a selection of meat and seafood dishes, such as grilled steaks, roasted chicken, and pan-seared scallops. These are prepared with precision and attention to detail, ensuring that each bite is a culinary delight. The restaurant's ambiance is equally impressive, with a warm and inviting space that is perfect for a special occasion or a romantic dinner. The attentive staff provides exceptional service, making every guest feel welcome and pampered. Thompson & Bleecker is not just a place to eat; it's a place to experience the art of fine dining in a relaxed and comfortable setting. Whether you are a local resident or a visitor exploring Ithaca's culinary landscape, a visit to Thompson & Bleecker is sure to impress.

Their takeout menu includes a selection of their most popular dishes, so you can enjoy restaurant-quality food from the comfort of your home. Be sure to check out their daily specials for exciting and seasonal options.

5. Agava Restaurant

Okay, so Agava Restaurant isn't strictly Italian, but they offer some fantastic Italian-inspired dishes with a southwestern twist. Their wood-fired pizzas are a must-try, and they have a great selection of pasta dishes that incorporate local ingredients. Agava Restaurant brings a unique and vibrant dining experience to Ithaca, blending Southwestern flavors with Italian influences. This restaurant is known for its innovative menu, which features dishes prepared with locally sourced ingredients and cooked in a wood-fired oven. While Agava isn't strictly an Italian restaurant, its Italian-inspired dishes are a standout feature, offering a creative twist on classic favorites. Their wood-fired pizzas are a must-try, with options ranging from traditional Margherita to more adventurous combinations like roasted corn and poblano peppers. The dough is made fresh daily and baked to a perfect char, providing a crispy and flavorful base for their array of toppings. In addition to their pizzas, Agava also offers a selection of pasta dishes that incorporate Southwestern ingredients and spices. The green chile macaroni and cheese is a popular choice, as is the butternut squash ravioli with sage butter and toasted pecans. The restaurant's commitment to using local and sustainable ingredients ensures that each dish is fresh, flavorful, and reflective of the region's culinary heritage. The ambiance at Agava is warm and inviting, with a rustic-chic decor that complements the Southwestern theme. The friendly staff provides excellent service, making every guest feel welcome and comfortable. Whether you are looking for a casual meal with friends or a special occasion dinner, Agava Restaurant offers a unique and memorable dining experience. It's a place where you can explore new flavors, support local farmers, and enjoy the best of both Southwestern and Italian cuisine.

Tips for Ordering Italian Carryout

To make the most of your Italian carryout experience in Ithaca, here are a few tips:

• Check Online Menus: Most restaurants have their menus available online, so you can plan your order in advance.
• Call Ahead: Especially during peak hours, calling ahead can save you a lot of time.
• Ask About Specials: Some restaurants offer daily or weekly specials that aren’t always listed on the regular menu.
• Consider Delivery Options: If you don’t feel like picking up your order, check if the restaurant offers delivery services.

Conclusion

So, there you have it! Ithaca, NY, offers a variety of fantastic Italian carryout options to satisfy your cravings. Whether you're in the mood for classic pasta dishes, mouth-watering pizzas, or innovative Italian-inspired cuisine, you're sure to find something to love. Grab your takeout, find a cozy spot, and enjoy the delicious flavors of Italy right here in Ithaca!

Enjoy your Italian feast, guys! Buon appetito!