Hey pizza lovers! If you're on the hunt for the most famous pizza in NYC, then you've absolutely got to check out what the folks on Reddit are saying. Seriously, these guys and gals are passionate about their slices, and they've got some seriously strong opinions. So, grab a napkin, get ready to drool, and let's dive into the delicious world of New York City pizza, according to the Reddit community! I'm talking about legendary spots, hidden gems, and everything in between. Whether you're a local or just visiting, this guide is your key to unlocking the best pizza experiences NYC has to offer. We'll be exploring different styles, from classic New York slices to wood-fired creations, and uncovering the must-visit pizzerias that consistently earn rave reviews. Get ready to discover your new favorite pizza place, because after reading this, you'll be craving a slice ASAP!

The Classic New York Slice: Where to Begin?

Alright, let's start with the basics. When you think of NYC pizza, chances are you're picturing that iconic New York slice: thin crust, slightly crispy, foldable, and with that perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and a little bit of grease (don't judge, it's part of the experience!). Reddit has no shortage of opinions on where to find the ultimate classic. So, where do the Reddit pizza aficionados direct you? First off, you gotta understand that everyone has their own taste, but there are a few places that consistently pop up in conversations, earning them a special place in the hearts (and stomachs) of many Redditors.

One of the biggest names you'll see tossed around is Lombardi's. Located in Little Italy, Lombardi's is often credited as the first pizzeria in the United States, opening its doors way back in 1905. It's a historical landmark, and many Redditors say it lives up to the hype, though some find it a bit overrated due to the massive lines and tourist crowds. But hey, it's a must-try for the history alone! Another heavyweight contender is Joe's Pizza, with multiple locations across the city. Joe's is celebrated for its consistently excellent, no-frills slice. It's the kind of place you can grab a quick, delicious meal anytime, and it's a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The simplicity of Joe's is part of its charm. They focus on perfecting the basics, and the results speak for themselves. Their slice is a quintessential representation of the New York style, and it's a safe bet for a satisfying pizza experience.

Then there's Artichoke Basille's Pizza. Though not a classic in the traditional sense, they've become a staple in the NYC pizza scene. Their signature artichoke slice is a rich, creamy, and decadent experience that's unlike anything else. While it may not be for everyone, it's definitely a must-try for those looking for something different. The sheer popularity of Artichoke Basille's is a testament to its deliciousness and innovative approach. Their willingness to experiment with flavors and toppings has made them a hit, drawing crowds of hungry pizza fans who are always up for a slice of something unique.

Beyond the Classic: Exploring Pizza Styles

Okay, so we've covered the classic New York slice, but NYC pizza is so much more than that! The city is a melting pot of culinary influences, and this is reflected in the diverse range of pizza styles you can find. Reddit users are always eager to share their favorite spots for different types of pizza, so let's check out a few.

First up, we have Neapolitan pizza. This style is all about simplicity and quality ingredients. Authentic Neapolitan pizza is cooked in a wood-fired oven at extremely high temperatures, resulting in a blistered crust and a soft, slightly wet center. Roberta's in Bushwick is frequently mentioned as a top contender for Neapolitan-style pizza. They're known for their innovative toppings, excellent dough, and overall commitment to quality. Roberta's is more than just a pizzeria; it's a neighborhood institution. The atmosphere is vibrant and inviting, making it a great place to hang out with friends and enjoy some fantastic pizza. Also, Motorino, with a few locations, consistently gets high praise for its Neapolitan pies. Their dedication to using fresh, high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques shines through in every bite. They also have an amazing selection of toppings that keeps their customers coming back for more.

Next, there's Sicilian pizza. This is a rectangular pizza with a thick, airy crust, often topped with a generous amount of sauce and cheese. Reddit users often recommend L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn for an authentic Sicilian experience. This spot is a true institution, serving up delicious pizza and spumoni for generations. The crust at L&B is legendary, and their pizza is a must-try for any pizza enthusiast. The combination of the fluffy crust, flavorful sauce, and perfectly melted cheese is simply irresistible. This is a pizza experience that will transport you straight to Sicily. Another great option is Rubirosa, in Nolita. They are known for their thin crust and their delicious sauce. They also do a very good job with their toppings. Also, they offer a great vibe for the night out.

Reddit's Hidden Gems: Underrated Pizza Spots

Alright, now let's get into the really good stuff: the hidden gems. These are the places that Redditors swear by, the spots that might not be as famous as Lombardi's or Joe's but are equally (or even more) delicious. These are the places you'll want to impress your friends with when you're looking for an off-the-beaten-path pizza adventure. When searching for the most famous pizza in NYC, always keep an eye out for these spots that are loved by Reddit's community.

One spot that consistently gets a shout-out is Paulie Gee's. With multiple locations, Paulie Gee's offers a unique take on pizza, with creative toppings and a focus on quality ingredients. Their Hellboy pizza, with soppressata and hot honey, is practically a religious experience for some Redditors. The atmosphere is always lively, and the pizzas are consistently delicious. Paulie Gee's is a great place to try something different and discover new flavor combinations. Their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and experimenting with toppings sets them apart from the crowd. Another solid recommendation is Pizza Secret, which may not be the most well-known pizzeria, but it's famous among the Reddit community. With a focus on quality and consistency, their delicious pizza will have you coming back for more.

Also, a great recommendation is Scarr's Pizza. Situated in the Lower East Side, Scarr's Pizza, is praised for their outstanding pizza quality. Scarr's is committed to using only high-quality ingredients, from the dough to the sauce to the toppings. What makes Scarr's truly special is the care and attention that goes into every single pizza. Their dedication to quality is evident in every bite, making it a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. The atmosphere at Scarr's is always buzzing. It's a place where you can relax, enjoy a great pizza, and feel like you're part of the local scene. Scarr's Pizza is a testament to the fact that great pizza starts with great ingredients and a passion for the craft.

The Verdict: So, Where Should You Go?

So, there you have it, folks! A whirlwind tour of NYC pizza as seen through the eyes of the Reddit community. Remember, taste is subjective, and what one person loves, another might not. But the places mentioned here consistently get high praise, and they're a great place to start your own pizza exploration. I think it is important to remember a few things when embarking on your own pizza journey. First, be adventurous! Don't be afraid to try new styles and toppings. Second, do your research. Check out reviews and see what others are saying before you head out. Finally, be patient. The best pizza places often have long lines, but trust me, it's usually worth the wait!

To recap, if you're looking for a classic New York slice, head to Joe's Pizza or Lombardi's. For something different, check out Artichoke Basille's Pizza. If you're into Neapolitan-style pizza, Roberta's or Motorino are great choices. For Sicilian pizza, L&B Spumoni Gardens is the place to be. And for hidden gems, don't miss Paulie Gee's, Scarr's Pizza and Pizza Secret. Ultimately, the best pizza is the one you enjoy the most. So get out there, explore, and find your own favorite slice of heaven. Happy eating, pizza lovers!