Toyota 86 GT Vs Subaru BRZ: Which Sports Car Wins?

So, you're eyeing a fun, sporty ride and have narrowed it down to the Toyota 86 GT and the Subaru BRZ. Good choice, guys! These cars are practically twins, sharing the same DNA and being born from a joint venture between Toyota and Subaru. But, like any siblings, they have their subtle differences. Let's dive deep and figure out which one deserves a spot in your garage. We'll explore everything from performance and handling to styling and features, so you can make an informed decision. Buckle up; it's going to be a fun ride!

Under the Hood: Identical Twins?

When you peek under the hood, you'll find that both the Toyota 86 GT and Subaru BRZ pack the same punch: a 2.0-liter naturally aspirated boxer engine. This engine layout, with its horizontally opposed cylinders, gives both cars a low center of gravity, which is crucial for excellent handling. Now, let's talk numbers. We're looking at around 205 horsepower and 156 lb-ft of torque (for models with a manual transmission; automatic versions get slightly less). While that might not sound like a ton of power in today's world of turbocharged beasts, remember that these cars are all about balance and driving experience. It’s not just about straight-line speed; it’s about how the car feels when you're carving through corners. The engine loves to rev, and you'll find yourself frequently exploring the upper reaches of the tachometer to extract the most from it. The power delivery is linear, which means there are no sudden surges or surprises – just a smooth, predictable increase in power as you climb through the rev range. This makes it easy to control and a blast to drive, especially on winding roads. While some might complain about a lack of low-end torque, the engine's character encourages you to be an active driver, constantly shifting gears to keep it in the sweet spot. Both cars are available with either a six-speed manual or a six-speed automatic transmission. Purists will likely prefer the manual, which offers a more engaging and direct connection to the driving experience. The automatic, however, is surprisingly responsive and offers paddle shifters for those who want to take control of gear changes. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference. But mechanically speaking, the engines are virtually identical so no advantage is awarded to either the BRZ or 86 here.

Handling and Performance: Where the Magic Happens

Okay, guys, this is where things get interesting. While the engine is the same, Toyota and Subaru have tweaked the suspension and chassis settings slightly, giving each car a unique feel on the road. The Subaru BRZ generally has a slightly softer suspension setup compared to the Toyota 86 GT. This translates to a more compliant ride over bumps and imperfections in the road. It makes the BRZ a bit more comfortable for daily driving, especially if you live in an area with rough roads. However, that added compliance also means that the BRZ might exhibit slightly more body roll in corners compared to the 86. The Toyota 86 GT, on the other hand, typically features a slightly stiffer suspension. This gives it a sharper, more responsive feel when you're pushing it hard. The stiffer setup minimizes body roll and provides a more direct connection to the road. This can make the 86 feel more engaging and precise on a track or on twisty mountain roads. However, the firmer ride might be less forgiving on rough surfaces. The differences aren't massive, but enthusiasts will definitely notice them. Think of it this way: the BRZ is slightly more forgiving and comfortable for everyday use, while the 86 is slightly more focused and rewarding when driven aggressively. In terms of steering, both cars offer sharp, precise steering that provides plenty of feedback from the road. This allows you to place the car exactly where you want it and inspires confidence when cornering. The brakes are also excellent, providing strong stopping power and a firm pedal feel. Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to your driving style and preferences. Do you prioritize comfort and compliance, or do you prefer a sharper, more responsive feel? Test drive both cars and see which one resonates with you.

Styling and Design: A Matter of Taste

Let's be honest, guys, both the Toyota 86 GT and Subaru BRZ are head-turners. They boast a sleek, sporty design with a low-slung stance and aggressive lines. But, there are subtle differences in their styling that might sway you one way or the other. The front fascia is the most noticeable difference. The Toyota 86 GT typically features a more aggressive front bumper with a larger grille and sharper angles. This gives it a more menacing and sporty look. The Subaru BRZ, on the other hand, usually has a slightly more understated front bumper with a smaller grille and smoother lines. This gives it a more refined and sophisticated appearance. Around back, the differences are more subtle. Both cars feature a rear spoiler and dual exhaust outlets, but the design of the taillights and rear bumper can vary slightly. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference. Do you prefer the more aggressive look of the 86, or the more refined look of the BRZ? Inside, the differences are even more subtle. Both cars feature a driver-focused cockpit with supportive seats, a sporty steering wheel, and simple, easy-to-use controls. The materials used are generally good for the price point, although some might find them a bit basic. The biggest difference inside might be in the badging and trim options. Toyota and Subaru each offer different interior color combinations and trim accents, allowing you to personalize your car to your liking. Overall, both cars offer a stylish and sporty design that is sure to turn heads. The choice between the two comes down to your personal taste and which one you find more appealing.

Interior and Features: What's Inside Counts

Okay, so we've talked about performance and looks, but what about the inside? Both the Toyota 86 GT and Subaru BRZ offer a pretty similar interior experience. Don't expect luxury-level appointments, guys, because these cars are all about the driving experience. The focus is on functionality and keeping the driver connected to the road. The seats are supportive and comfortable, even on longer drives. They're designed to hold you in place during spirited driving, which is a definite plus. The driving position is excellent, with all the controls within easy reach. The steering wheel feels great in your hands, and the shifter (if you opt for the manual) is precise and satisfying to use. In terms of features, both cars come standard with the basics, such as air conditioning, power windows and locks, and a basic audio system. Higher trim levels add features like a touchscreen infotainment system, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility, and upgraded audio systems. However, don't expect a ton of cutting-edge technology. These cars are designed to be simple and straightforward, prioritizing the driving experience over flashy gadgets. One thing to note is that the rear seats are pretty small. They're technically there, but they're really only suitable for small children or for extra storage space. If you regularly need to carry passengers in the back, you might want to consider a different car. Overall, the interior of both the 86 and BRZ is functional and driver-focused. It's not luxurious, but it provides everything you need to enjoy the driving experience. The key is to not expect a lot of frills; these cars are about raw driving pleasure.

Reliability and Ownership: Long-Term Considerations

Now, let's talk about something practical: reliability and ownership costs. Both the Toyota 86 GT and Subaru BRZ have generally proven to be reliable cars. However, like any vehicle, they're not immune to potential issues. One common concern with earlier models was a potential for engine issues, particularly related to oil consumption. However, these issues seem to have been addressed in later models. Regular maintenance is key to keeping both cars running smoothly. Be sure to follow the manufacturer's recommended service schedule, which includes regular oil changes, filter replacements, and other routine maintenance tasks. In terms of ownership costs, both cars are relatively affordable to own. Fuel economy is decent, especially if you're not constantly driving them hard. Insurance costs are also reasonable, considering their sporty nature. Parts and maintenance costs are generally in line with other cars in their class. One thing to consider is that the Subaru BRZ typically comes with a slightly longer warranty than the Toyota 86 GT. This could provide some added peace of mind. Ultimately, both cars are relatively reliable and affordable to own. With proper care and maintenance, they should provide you with years of driving enjoyment. Be sure to do your research and read reviews from other owners to get a better sense of their long-term reliability.

The Verdict: Which Twin Should You Choose?

So, after all that, which one should you choose: the Toyota 86 GT or the Subaru BRZ? Honestly, guys, it's a tough call. These cars are so similar that it really comes down to personal preference. If you prioritize a slightly more comfortable ride and a more understated look, the Subaru BRZ might be the better choice for you. If you prefer a sharper, more responsive feel and a more aggressive look, the Toyota 86 GT might be more your style. Consider these points to make a decision:

• Test Drive is a Must: The best way to decide is to test drive both cars back-to-back. See which one feels better to you and which one you enjoy driving more.
• Suspension Preference: The BRZ has a softer suspension and is better at daily driving. The 86 GT has a stiffer suspension, making it better for a performance environment.
• Styling Choice: The style is an important factor. If you like a sporty look, the 86 GT is the best choice. If you want a minimalist approach, go with the BRZ.
• Pricing and Availability: Check prices and availability in your area. Sometimes one might be easier to find or offer a better deal than the other.

Ultimately, you can't go wrong with either car. They're both fantastic sports cars that offer a thrilling driving experience. Just choose the one that speaks to you the most, and get ready to have some fun! Remember that these cars are more about the experience than practicality, so keep your use case in mind when purchasing either the Toyota 86 GT or Subaru BRZ.